Big Joy: How-To Videos From Designer Jen Geigley

By Kay Gardiner
September 11, 2019
Field Guide No. 12: Big Joy is full of knits that will make everyone happy, especially the knitter.

Leave a Comment

17 Comments
  • The “no knots in knitting” crowd will be having apoplexy this morning. Interesting videos.

    • I am in the no-knots crowd myself, but I enjoy it when somebody gets up in my grill about it!

    • I have been using magic knot for several years and I have never had one fail or show in a finished project. I would never do it in front of my no knot friends who would be clutching their pearls as I snip off the ends close to the ends.

  • These are fantastic! I look forward to referring to these videos when I knit these patterns.

  • Question: what do you do with the ends after the magic knot? Cut them off? Weave them in?

    • I asked Jen and she says she weaves hers in. Personally I am going to do at least one scrappy hat where I leave the ends on the outside like a shag rug.

  • This a great! Would LOVE to have these kind of videos for the Field Guide 11. Is that a possibility? I’ve had to search YouTube for tutorials and it would be fantastic to see some based off the Guide.

  • Many people have had problems with the magic knot in knitting. It relies on tension to work, but the yarn in knitting isn’t under tension. The two ends come loose and the knitting unravels.

    This has happened to many people (check out Ravelry for horror stories), including a friend and her lace shawl. I was able to recreate the knitting and “fix” it, but her shawl ended up with four ends woven into it. It was a cautionary tale for everyone in my knitting group!

    What I do is splice my ends. My “No End Stripes” video on youtube shows how to knit striped shawls and scarves with only one end to weave in — the bind off.

    • The idea that the knot relies on tension to work is simply not true. I have used Magic Knots – more accurately, the fisherman’s knot or angler’s knot – for years, on garments that have been washed & dried many times. Case in point, it was used 5+ years ago to join slippery rayon chenille for a project that was then machine washed & dried – not gently – to create a panne fabric. Not. one. knot. failed. Then or since, & a cowl is hardly worn “under tension.” If a Magic Knot fails, it was not tied properly to begin with.

      • Glad it works for you! To each his or her own.

      • Another explanation for failures such as my friend’s is “user error.” I can’t speak for myself since I only used this joining method once, in a shawl I sent off to charity. After reading about so many magic knot fails on Ravelry I sure hoped that my knot held, but I’ll never know!

  • Question for Jen: did you make a how-to video for your Knitted Pie Crust? I can’t picture how to “knit” stk.st.

    • Stay tuned, we are just getting this rolled out (yes this is a pie pun)! If you are in a hurry to bake your pie, I can say that I did it from the explanation and photo in the Field Guide, and it worked perfectly the first time!

      • Rolled out, hahahaha
        I’ll wait for the video; I’m a visual learner

  • What do you do with the tails? Do you knit double stranded for a while, cut the tails. Please explain.

  • Thank you for magic knot! I have been making scrappy hats all summer and this will help speed up the process! I donate most of them to schools or women’s shelters. I do agree they turn out to be adorable!