Knit Detective: The Eddie Redmayne Sweater

Leave a Comment

39 Comments
  • I stared and stared at that stitch pattern and just couldn’t make sense of it. So cool, Julia. Sherlock Holmes has nothing on you.

    • Agreed….. I can look at this time & again & still I want to look again but I really want to feel it.

  • This journey has been so exciting to watch. You, and a few others I follow on Instagram, and how you have so lovingly taken this on have been super inspiring to me. Thank you. I am challenged to take my knitting imagination up a notch.

    • What is her twitter name? I want more! Oh, Julia Farwell-Clay….

      • @farwellclay

  • Brava, Julia! I’m in awe of your investigative skills and knitting talent. (I’ve yet to decide whether I actually like the Prada version …)

  • You are brilliant beyond all reason and also I kind of want that one-color version as a scarf or a hat. (If I tried to knit even the one-color version as a sweater I’m pretty sure I’d be doing it for the next twenty years. Although I bet the stripy version would look super cute on my daughter…. and she’s much smaller.)

  • Well done!

  • Amazing! I’m pretty sure that’s the fiercest bit of knitting code breaking ever. Also,I’m totally going to start tying a knot and getting on with it. If it’s okay with Kaffe (and with Prada) then it’s okay with me.

  • This is one of the best detective stories I’ve read in ages! Utterly captivating, and I can’t wait to see where you take this now that you’ve unraveled (ha) the secret of the pattern!

    • I was wondering how to express my thoughts on this article and you nailed it with ‘utterly captivating’.
      Hopefully Prada reply……..

    • I third that – utterly captivating sums it up perfectly. Julia, since you are a professional designer who sells patterns, I am curious. I know from friends who design sewing patterns that copyright lines for design can be murky and confusing. Would you be comfortable releasing this stitch design as part of a pattern as long as you did not copy the sweater design itself, or do you feel that the stitch design belongs to Prada? What are your personal feelings about where the lines for copyright should be drawn?

      • This is a great question, Debbi, and I was hoping someone would ask. Long answer ahead, but here’s my thesis: Stitch patterns are most of the time just stitch patterns. As many times a 2 over 2 cable has been used, it’s all fair in yarn and knitting. There are such things as stitch patterns that have something approaching copyright, such as just about everything in Norah Gaughan’s new book of cables, and a few other exceptional things knitters have worked out over the years. I’ve always felt that the Oak Leaf cable first worked out (to the best of my knowledge) around 1996 by Julie Weisenberger for Knitter’s Magazine Great American Afghan, should always bear her name when designers put it into their hat patterns. But most of knitting is fair game, existing in the common knowledge for all of us to be inspired by, to use, and even ::cough:: to sell. After all, designers are mindful and often explicit about their borrowing from Barbara Walker’s contribution to the stitch lexicon, as she herself was in her Treasuries, always giving credit to knitters who submitted to her collection. I too think credit should be given where it is possible, but constant refashioning from our collective knowledge is what keeps tradition going. It is a necessary and vital part of the craft.

        In this case, the modular scallop is hazy in its origin. It might be attributable to Madeline Langan and her felted Stained Glass Bag from the early 00’s, but it might be earlier. However, the technique has grown wings and become so many things since then, it is almost its own genre, much like entrelac.

        In the case of “The Prada Sweater”, I myself am attempting to find out the origin story of the design. I have a request in through a few channels, and I will certainly let knitters know if I get an answer. In the meantime, here is my best guess. There is a class of knitter whose livelihood is to generate swatches on spec, that is, they put together stitch patterns or fair isle charts, and they bundle them for sale to interested fashion houses through an agent. The Agent, representing her swatch designer clients, takes the whole batch for the fashion house to paw through, and the fashion house – let’s call it Prada – chooses one or more and they pay for the right to use that swatch in their collection. It might get used, it might not. It might have been different in the original purchased swatch from the multi colored version you see on the runway. There’s a fair bit of alchemy evident here with “The Prada Sweater”, and my guess is that many cooks contributed to this fascinating dish. I can speculate a lot more here, but the pith of it is that the swatch designer has most likely borrowed from the collective lexicon themselves.

        And the collective can borrow it back.

        I think reproducing the sweater itself stitch for stitch – collar, pocket and all – then selling the pattern with one’s name attached is unlikely to evoke any reaction from the fashion industry. Goodness knows they’ve done it to friends of mine, and intellectual property in fashion is a murky business. But poaching or copying this sweater for profit (and the exchange of money is the key here) would be what I would interpret as “bad form” on the part of that copyist.

        However: the modular scallop already exists: I used a version of it for my own cardigan design, the Burton Hills Jacket just last year. For other examples see Aranami by Olga Buraya-Kefelian or the Seashell Scrap Yarn Blanket by Charan Sachar. The scallop in The Prada Sweater seems new and different because the sweater adds the intarsia variable. It really got our attention, but it’s still just the modular scallop. Now that there seems to be interest in the technique, I think that teaching it in a class, or to applying that scallop to mittens or a hat then selling THAT as a pattern is a different thing, and in my opinion, fair game.

        I will admit that I’m planing to knit a version of The Prada Sweater, but it will be different. It will be longer, of an entirely different palette. And here’s the critical factor as I understand it: I won’t be selling the pattern for that sweater.

  • Pure genius!! Bravo!

  • I love knitting articles like this! They’re like Cook’s Illustrated articles only for knitting. They make me think and inspire me to do things I didn’t think I could do. Keep ’em coming! And great job JFC!

  • Let me know if you want someone to travel this journey with you. I would LOVE to make this. Kaffe Fassett is my hero and I could so play with all those colors. Amazing!!

    • This detective adventure has added so much to my knitting journey. ..

  • Julia, you are a marvel, your enthusiasm for knitting and design are unparalleled and it is catching.

  • A++++++

  • As an esteemed friend says, I BOW DOWN. This was a thrill to read!

  • And Prada had the good sense to choose an experienced knitwear model
    http://www.ravelry.com/patterns/library/brooklyn
    In case link doesn’t work lookup the Rowan patterns Brooklyn ( on Rav) and Google for Saucers and Redmayne.

  • Hooray! Respect for knots in knitting, and not just from Julia, which would already be a mighty checkmark in favor, but Kaffe himself. I’ve never understood the resistance to knotting ends on the wrong side, and have done it somewhat abashedly for years. Now I will do so proudly!

    • I find this to be the most freeing piece of information of the day. I hate weaving in, and I resist making some colorwork items for that reason. I think I just changed my mind!

  • Fascinating. I cut out that ad from the NYT and have looked and looked at it. this article is so interesting, I will re-read it over and over to understand better and also because I am obsessed with the colors, design, and technique.

  • Totally love this!!

  • I also saw the sweater in the ad, and hunted down ads in NYTimes, Vogue and FT. But that was the end of the story for me. I was impressed and facinated by your story. Well done and thank you!

  • Nice article.

  • I don’t know if I could knit my knitting…seems so sacrilegious. What am I talking about…I am the girl who in Catholic high school used cig ashes instead of going to mass.

  • Thank you, Julia. I was obsessed with it, too, and also figured out short rows were one of the secrets. I preferred the colors of the women’s vest I saw in the NYT to those in Eddie R’s – and yours are nice as well.
    This stitch pattern seems a good way to use my stash of no longer produced Rowan LDK…

  • Fantastic, Julia! And remember that the great Hazel Find all also knots on the back.

    • Darn that Autocorrect: I know you meant Hazel Tindall

  • I love stories of (minor fun) obsessions like this! Reassuring to know I’m not the only one who goes down rabbit holes! Thank you for sharing…and I hope to see photos of the work in progress!

  • Ain’t nothin’ to it but to do it! Get in there, girl. You’re amazing. This whole Prada sweater story has me in such fits of delight!

    Love you geniuses!

  • Beyond fabulous! Thank you for the knitterly sleuthing. When I saw this sweater in Vogue (I was standing in line at the pharmacy) I gasped loudly. People turned and stared, looking for an emergency, so I quickly said, “I’m fine, it’s ok, it’s just this sweater, it’s, I, um, wow.” I was quickly reminded I was not among knitters. Grateful to know I’m not alone.

  • I didn’t read all the comments so please excuse if this has been suggested. I think this would be a suitable project for this pattern: http://www.ravelry.com/patterns/library/boulevard-6

  • What a fascinating story! Thank you! I hope to read what Prada has to say about the design…even if it’s “no comment.”

  • Also, I have been and continue to be fascinated by the scallop shape. I considered using a modular scallop design to evoke multiple fossil shells for a shawl this summer. (Which I is how I often find them on the beach—piled higgledey-piggledey for eons.) I ended up using Nicola Susen’s “Seashell” design instead, for one great big scallop fossil shell shawl!

  • I love this, i’m glad to see i’m not the only one who scrutinizes what they see on the runway!

  • Bravo!