Hey Ann: Here’s your store! Cheese and Antiques (in that order). Note also the little sign in the window assuring you that yes, they do have ‘fresh coffee’.
I didn’t go in to see if the place sold cheese in your favorite form (Chee-toes), or if by any chance there were any of those $450 swifts or $8700 barrel-people you adore. We’ll save this place as a treat for that New York visit you keep telling me you’re planning. It’s in the 60s off Central Park West.